Summer 2024 Retrospective
I was challenged to watch every anime this season (that I realistically could). That means that while I didn't have to watch any sequels I wasn't caught up to, I had to watch everything else. And I succeeded, with a caveat. I didn't watch the Rick and Morty anime. You might say that it doesn't even count as anime - MAL still, as of posting, has it "pending approval" despite that being the case for months and the show ending its run already - or that, because it's part of an established brand and I am not caught up on the main show, that it shouldn't be needed ... but I'll say I didn't get to it and it should count.
But apart from that? I did it, you guys. I either have finished or am still watching 49 of the 54 shows from the season, with 4 of the ones I had to skip being sequels I'm not caught up on, and then Rick and Morty: The Anime.
Was it worth it? It was not worth it. It's too much for one person, especially when this isn't my job. Make it my job and, yeah, sure. But on top of a job? And on top of the other retrospective shows? Yup, there is too much anime. But I did it anyway. And I'm not saying I won't ever do it again. But probably not for a while, or not until I somehow figure out a way to make a job out of it.
So let's talk about this season. You know I like to talk about stats first, so let's get to those.
By my count, there are 54 full-length series that started to air this season. They add up to 690 episodes - not counting OVAs. 41 of these shows are new, while 13 of them are continuations (read: sequels) from previous seasons. I am not including long-running shows in these numbers; those will be included only in the season in which they began.
Here are the shows that are being included:
2.5 Dimensional Seduction (Season 1) | In Progress |
---|---|
Alya Sometimes Hides Her Feelings in Russian (Season 1) | Complete |
Atri: My Dear Moments (Season 1) | Complete |
Bye Bye, Earth (Season 1) | Complete |
Code Geass: Rozé of the Recapture (Season 1) | Complete |
Dahlia in Bloom: Crafting a Fresh Start with Magical Tools (Season 1) | Complete |
Days with My Stepsister (Season 1) | Complete |
Delico's Nursery (Season 1) | In Progress |
Dungeon People (Season 1) | Complete |
The Elusive Samurai (Season 1) | Complete |
Failure Frame: I Became the Strongest and Annihilated Everything With Low-Level Spells (Season 1) | Complete |
Grendizer U (Season 1) | Complete |
I Parry Everything (Season 1) | Complete |
A Journey Through Another World: Raising Kids While Adventuring (Season 1) | Complete |
Love Is Indivisible by Twins (Season 1) | Complete |
The Magical Girl and the Evil Lieutenant Used to Be Archenemies (Season 1) | Complete |
Makeine: Too Many Losing Heroines! (Season 1) | Complete |
Mayonaka Punch (Season 1) | Complete |
Monogatari Series: Off & Monster Season (Season 1) | Complete |
My Deer Friend Nokotan (Season 1) | Complete |
My Wife Has No Emotion (Season 1) | Complete |
Narenare -Cheer for You!- (Season 1) | Complete |
No Longer Allowed In Another World (Season 1) | Complete |
A Nobody's Way Up to an Exploration Hero (Season 1) | Complete |
The Ossan Newbie Adventurer, Trained to Death by the Most Powerful Party, Became Invincible (Season 1) | Complete |
Plus-Sized Elf (Season 1) | Complete |
Pseudo Harem (Season 1) | Complete |
Quality Assurance in Another World (Season 1) | Complete |
Ramen Akaneko (Season 1) | Complete |
Rick & Morty: The Anime (Season 1) | Unwatched |
Sakuna: Of Rice and Ruin (Season 1) | Complete |
Senpai Is an Otokonoko (Season 1) | Complete |
Shoshimin: How to Become Ordinary (Season 1) | Complete |
The Strongest Magician in the Demon Lord's Army Was a Human (Season 1) | Complete |
Suicide Squad Isekai (Season 1) | Complete |
Tasuketsu: Fate of the Majority (Season 1) | In Progress |
Terminator Zero (Season 1) | Complete |
Twilight Out of Focus (Season 1) | Complete |
VTuber Legend: How I Went Viral after Forgetting to Turn Off My Stream (Season 1) | Complete |
Why Does Nobody Remember Me in This World? (Season 1) | Complete |
Wistoria: Wand and Sword (Season 1) | Complete |
NieR:Automata Ver1.1a (Season 1.2) | Complete |
Sengoku Youko (Season 1.2) | In Progress |
The Café Terrace and Its Goddesses (Season 2) | Complete |
[Oshi no Ko] (Season 2) | Complete |
Our Last Crusade or the Rise of a New World (Season 2) | Delayed |
Rising Impact (Season 2) | Unwatched |
Shy (Season 2) | Complete |
T.P Bon (Season 2) | Unwatched |
Tower of God (Season 2.1) | Complete |
Kengan Ashura (Season 2.2) | Unwatched |
Kimi ni Todoke: From Me to You (Season 3) | Complete |
Ultimate Muscle (Season 3) | Unwatched |
Fairy Tail (Season 4) | In Progress |
Review
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Alya Sometimes Hides Her Feelings in Russian is an anime about a girl who does the tsundere thing but reveals
her true feelings toward protag-kun in Russian ... but he understands her thanks to a childhood friend he liked for
whom he learned the language. And also he has a sister who is very flirty with him. And there are like 3 or 4 other
girls who are just wonderful, too. But the sister and eponymous Alya steal the show most of the time.
The story? What story? Okay, okay, it eventually settles on a student council election that drags on for too long. The
show is at its best when it's the characters hanging out or flirting or doing anything that isn't especially goal-oriented.
This means it drags a bit in its second half and, after the initial rush of "wow there's a lot of great girls here," wears
off. But it's still good fun, it looks great (it was delayed before release, not during, thankfully, which allowed it to be
released polished), and I'll look forward to more in the future.
Long Story Short
Alya Sometimes Hides Her Feelings in Russian gives us enough great cute anime girls that I don't care that
its plot is kind of a drag. |
---|
Review
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Atri: My Dear Moments looks great. It's made by TROYCA, who usually do good work, and it's based on a visual novel
I'll never read/play but was received quite well. And, visually, it is fantastic. The animation is fluid, the characters are
detailed, and I never once didn't enjoy looking at the pictures on screen. And given how I usually don't spend this much
time on visuals, you've probably already guessed that it's masking the rest of the show.
It's not that the story here is bad, or the characters are weak ... but it is disappointing, especially as it steers toward its
conclusion. It goes a little off the rails. We couldn't just keep it a light and fluffy story about a robot girl helping our
protag-kun fix up his village after it was devastated by climate change, huh? There are some interesting ideas on display
here - robot/android vs humans, the aforementioned climate change - but there's also an ill-advised romance at its core
that you can't just overlook.
Long Story Short
Atri: My Dear Moments gets by on its visuals and isn't ever dull but it winds up not living up to its potential. |
---|
Review
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Bye Bye, Earth initially was listed at double the episode count that we wound up getting in this season. Was this a
MAL error or was its second half not ready in time? We'll never know, but I'll blame MAL because, well, look at MAL.
The show is about a girl who was born in a world where everyone except for her is a furry, so she goes on a quest to
try to find another non-furry. Also, she's very close to her sword. Like, a little too comfortable.
It's a very mixed bag. There's a lot of worldbuilding - it's set in a complex world with a lot of lore to explore and so much
going on - but it never feels like enough to make the show not feel confusing. And at only 10 episodes, we're left
wanting. And confused. We're left confused a lot, too. Why does a lot of what happens, happen? Maybe we'll find out
whenever we get more. I feel like most people aren't going to give it that chance. And I can't blame them. This
type of thing often doesn't work out well for the audience.
Long Story Short
Bye Bye, Earth spends 10 episodes throwing a lot of ideas at the wall, but it isn't coherent enough to be worth
recommending ... yet, at least. |
---|
Review
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Is it fun that we got more Code Geass. after the franchise most certainly should have been over after its second
season? Sure, I guess. And are the cameos from the characters we grew to like over the earlier 50 episodes enjoyable?
Yeah, they are. But does Rozé of the Recapture reach the heights already established by the earlier entries? Nope.
It's a decent distraction with some enjoyable characters but it lacks a lot in comparison to previous installments.
The basic gist of it is that the Japanese are once again being oppressed and it's up to a rebel group to try to fix this.
It's a lot of the same stuff we've gotten before but without the genius-level planning. Or characters with as much
chemistry. The mecha battles are still decent and a couple of supporting cast members are great on their own
(Catherine spinoff when?) but it doesn't hold up when put into competition with its predecessors.
Long Story Short
Rozé of the Recapture will be remembered - if it's remembered - as a lacking installment in a storied franchise. |
---|
Review
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Dahlia in Bloom. a technicallysekai (I'm coining this if it isn't coined already) in which its protagonist uses
her powers of being a reincarnated person to create magical tools for the people of the fantasy world, like raincoats
and hair dryers. She uses magic to reproduce the technology from our world in her new one, which is cheating.
She's a cheater, and I'm not here to stand for this abuse of power!
She also gets cheated on, pretty early, by someone who was set up to be a controlling scumbag. The show doesn't
dwell on this potential darkness and provides a pretty smooth journey from here. Well, at least in terms of obstacles
our protagonist has to overcome. We have to overcome its lacking animation, which got worse and worse as time
went on. Not uncommon, but worth mentioning. And Dahlia is kind of boring, as are most of the supporting characters.
Trails and tribulations inspire growth and allow us to bond with those overcoming them. We don't get a lot of that.
Long Story Short
Dahlia in Bloom doesn't have enough going on to make it worth watching. |
---|
Review
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Listen. Listen! I know you see the title Days with My Stepsister and the "romance" genre and your mind automatically
assumes the worst. As it should. This is anime, and we are all terrible people. But hear me out. What if I told you this
anime isn't, really, that bad? Really! I said "really"! It's mostly mood-setting and full of vibes, because our central
characters - new step-siblings who meet as teenagers and have to navigate this new facet of their lives - are too
bland to do anything even remotely spicy. Saved by banality!
They each have one or two things that the other helps them with, and there's a lot of contemplative silence scattered
throughout. The show always looks good - the art is great, even during the times when there's not a lot of animation
needed - and does establish the vibes early and often. But it takes a little more than that to be a slam dunk for me,
and this one is just kind of okay when all things are considered.
Long Story Short
Days with My Stepsister is a lot more wholesome than you'd expect given the title, but it's also lacking in excitement. |
---|
Review
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Dungeon People is an adorable little anime about an adventurer working in a dungeon she was
exploring, befriending the cute anime girl manager who runs the place. She gets to learn the ins and outs of running
a dungeon, with the various monsters, items, and whatnot being things that need care so that those
who choose to explore the dungeon have things to do. Have you ever played Roller Coaster Tycoon? It's like that but
with dungeons.
It's a cute show and it's always a pleasant watch. Our protagonist has more motivation than just doing this, but
most of its time is spent doing this. There's some action scattered throughout, both leads are fun to watch,
and their growing friendship is enjoyable. It doesn't have a ton of ambitions beyond that, and it gets a bit repetitive
midway through, but if you ever wanted to see how to run a dungeon, well now you've got this.
Long Story Short
Dungeon People is cute but lacking in ambition and substance. |
---|
Review
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
From the opening moment of The Elusive Samurai until its conclusion - save for a few sequences with CGI horses,
because anime never seems to do non-CGI horses anymore - you will feel the production values. This is a show that,
for lack of a better term because I am very tired, [i]goes hard[/i[. Its action scenes are fantastic, but even the moment-
to-moment parts look great. You can tell a lot of work has gone into elevating the work from its manga origins.
Its story is about a coward of a child noble who is really good at evading people but not great at fighting. After betrayals
and massacres, he winds up teaming up with a priest and several retainers as he tries to use his strengths to take back
what was taken from him. And we ... don't get that far on his quest in this season. It's a lot of recruiting and fighting
lesser villains, but it's all good stuff. It's necessary to do this and future seasons get to build on it. Let's hope they do.
Long Story Short
The Elusive Samurai's first season is very much a First Season, but it's so visually engaging that it's never dull. |
---|
Review
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Failure Frame: I Became the Strongest and Annihilated Everything With Low-Level Spells. From this title, you can
probably deduce everything you need to know. It's an isekai where the protagonist is given a "weak" skill that turns out
to be super overpowered. With a strong word like "annihilated," you can probably guess it's going to be edgelord
central - if you couldn't figure that out from the poster. What else do you need? You've seen a dozen of these already.
Well, I'll tell you Failure Frame's most hilarious gimmick. Seemingly at random, the protagonist will just become
awkward CGI. It's not always, and it's not done as a stylistic thing as far as I can tell. It seems like it was done
whenever they thought they could get away with it. And then, eventually, it stops happening as often, or at least as
noticeably. The rest of the show is still awful but, clearly, someone looked over their work and told the team to stop
this nonsense. That's the only defining aspect of the show, though, so ... yeah.
Long Story Short
Failure Frame is a generic edgy OP-protag revenge isekai. Which is a sentence that shouldn't be generic, but
here we are. Thanks, anime. |
---|
Review
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
As someone who "hates mecha anime," Grendizer U is the perfect example of a mecha anime that I don't like.
Previously, I had to give some vague answer without naming specifics, because I've enjoyed all of the Gundam
anime I've watched, apart from episodes of SEED Freedom on TV as a kid. But this one, based on a franchise that
has been long dead, fits the bill perfectly. My understanding is it's mostly been made to appeal to countries that have
old Mezinger episodes on repeat, and I'm not trying to yuck on their yum but ... it's very bad.
Basically, it comes down to this: There is too much content to fit into a cours of anime (the previous version
was 75 episodes). Things just sort of happen, and then keep on happening. Character relationships develop inorganically,
battles are over in a flash, and none of it makes any sense. Maybe, if you're already a fan, you'll understand everything
going on. But for us newcomers? Nope! I was tuning out pretty early on.
Long Story Short
Grendizer U tries to fit way too much into way too little, and winds up being bad for anyone not familiar with
the franchise. |
---|
Review
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
There are two "I'm the strongest but I don't know it" shows this season, and I Parry Everything is certainly one of
them! The gimmick here is our buff protagonist dude sucks at everything except parrying, which has given him low
self-esteem. So that leads to "hilarious" situations where he does something incredible but thinks anyone could've
done it. And then repeat that a few times and you've made it to 12 episodes!
The other one of these drops this gimmick midway through, which made it a lot more enjoyable. This one does
pair our protagonist with a cute anime girl - a sheltered royal type who thinks he's the coolest guy around after he
saves her in an early episode - but their adventures don't become much more than mildly entertaining. And I became
so tired of protag-kun that I wouldn't have cared if he missed a parry and died.
Long Story Short
I Parry Everything's gimmick runs thin pretty fast. |
---|
Review
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
There is only one reason to watch A Journey Through Another World: Raising Kids While Adventuring. It's in the title.
It's the kids. Our protagonist finds an abandoned set of twins in the woods and decides to bring them with him and raise
them. They're cute. They're also really strong, which he learns is why they were able to survive in the woods before he
found them. But mostly they're cute, and you watch the show because they're cute and you want to see them be
cute with their new adoptive father.
The rest of the show? Nah. The story is a lot of nothing - the twins' origin didn't matter to me at all, and it spends a
decent chunk of its second half on that - the characters are all bland, the animation is passable but nothing more, and
its comedic sense is ... lacking. It's one of those shows Japan puts out now and then to try to trick us into thinking
kids are good. Because declining birthrate or whatever.
Long Story Short
A Journey Through Another World: Raising Kids While Adventuring's title should be enough to tell you to stay away. |
---|
Review
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Maybe this is just a me problem, but I kind of wanted Love Is Indivisible by Twins to be ... spicier? It's an anime
about a pair of twins both falling for the same dude and then trying to navigate their feelings, the other twin's feelings,
and (seldomly) the guy's feelings. It's all very tame and winds up being frustrating. The girls have interesting
personalities, and sometimes the script even allows them to act based on those.
More often, though, it just wants them to do dumb drama, most of which could be resolved in a conversation or two.
Or maybe ask the dude what he thinks instead of just having him go along with whatever. The dude sucks, is
what I'm saying; this is why people want characters to have agency. It's a lot of banal melodrama, which should be
a contradictory phrase but somehow this anime makes it work.
Long Story Short
Love Is Indivisible by Twins is somehow filled with melodrama but is also very boring. |
---|
Review
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
It's Love After World Domination, magical girl edition. The Magical Girl and the Evil Lieutenant Used to Be Archenemies
follows an evil lieutenant and a magical girl as they hang out and go on dates and otherwise act very cutesy with each
other ... and that's about it. There's maybe more going on - the handlers of the magical girls seem to be up to something
and the Lieutenant's evil faction also, eventually, would be able to figure out what's going on - but the mangaka died
before the work could get to there, so this is about all we're going to get.
That means, in 12 half-length episodes, it's a lot of cutesy nothing. Is it entertaining? Yeah, it's fine. It looks great - thank
you, Bones - and it is never an unpleasant watch. It's just a shame to know it's never going to be more, and it's
just a pleasant distraction. There's a side character who shows up, is hilarious, and then mostly vanishes for the final
few episodes, too. @#$% I say to that! (If you know, you know.)
Long Story Short
The Magical Girl and the Evil Lieutenant Used to Be Archenemies is a lot of pleasant nothing. |
---|
Review
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Makeine: Too Many Losing Heroines! follows a dude as he befriends a trio of girls who are losers in the game of
love. Each girl gets the equivalent of an arc to resolve some of their feelings, and the guy is always there, sometimes
reluctantly, to offer emotional support in the form of friendship and/or food. It baits you with potential harem fantasy
nonsense and winds up just making the characters friends, which was nice to see for once.
The girls are based on archetypes but develop a little past them during their arcs. They're good girls, but the energetic
glutton one, Anna, laps the field. The dude is kind of bland, but that feels more by design than anything; it's not his
story, after all. And the production values are way higher than they needed to be for this kind of story. They're welcome,
don't get me wrong. It's just surprising. It's a delight to look at.
Long Story Short
Makeine: Too Many Losing Heroines! baits you with harem shenanigans but develops into a solid platonic friendship
anime about overcoming romantic woes. |
---|
Review
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Let's imagine for a second that I was pitching you an anime. You're the head of a production committee or something.
(Not a studio, but let's not get too into the weeds for the reasoning.) And I came to you with the pitch of "vampire
YouTubers." And you say "yes" before I get to the second part of it, which is that they're not allowed to use their
vampire powers. Mayonaka Punch is about a human teaming up with a bunch of vampires to try to get 1 million
subs on not-YouTube, and they're not allowed to use the vampire powers to do so (although they do, initially, try).
Oh, and the human girl gets canceled for doing an assault on camera on her previous channel, and this is her
comeback. The behind-the-scenes of making it big on YouTube has always been fascinating to me, someone who
would've loved to do that but knows it's not a realistic thing to chase. And the girls are cute here. The videos they
make aren't particularly interesting, and the vampire stuff was more annoying than fun. But it's worth watching if you
are interested in making videos or the behind-the-scenes stuff that comes with trying to be a content creator.
Long Story Short
Mayonaka Punch has a pretty niche potential audience, but I think it'll hit big for those in it. |
---|
Review
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Monogatari is a series I binged in about a week a few years ago. It's so engaging that I couldn't stop watching it.
Even its worst parts are better than most anime that is released. And as long as you can get past its weirder aspects
- the kind that you don't mention to people because that's how rumors start and how you get added to lists - it's a
fantastic series. And for a while, it looked like we'd never get more of it. Now we have, and it's every bit as great as
you remember.
This season is a few arcs put together to justify calling it a "season" - unlike some earlier entries where
they'd only be 4 episodes and get their own release. We get to follow most of the characters we knew from the past,
either with them being a focus character or showing up to help out. Or just cameo, in a couple of cases. The Shaft
visuals remain a delight, the dialogue continues to captivate, and I'm just so glad we got more of this, you guys.
Long Story Short
If you're caught up, this season of Monogatari is a must-watch. |
---|
Review
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
There are no more thoughts. There is only deer.
Okay, there are some thoughts. My Deer Friend Nokotan is a gag comedy about a deer girl befriending the most
popular girl in school (who formerly was a delinquent), and the two of them starting a deer club alongside the popular
girl's yandere sister and a girl who aspires to become a deer. Also, there are uncanny CGI deer everywhere. And
random things happen all the time.
Your tolerance for this sort of humor will directly correlate to how much you enjoy The Deer Anime™ and that's going
to be even more subjective than most of these sorts of things. I had a pretty good time with it, even if it's lacking in
the story and character department. Some segments didn't work at all, but most episodes had a few pretty big laughs.
The meta-commentary got to me just as much, if not more, than the gag humor.
Long Story Short
Deer. |
---|
Review
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
There are two anime about getting together with a robot this season, although My Wife Has No Emotion takes it
more seriously and more literally. The "wife" in question is a chore robot who does not try to act like a real person.
There are upgraded models that do, but not this one. And the dude ... prefers it this way. Anyway, he decides, mostly
due to his lack of charisma, that he loves this robot, and proposes they become a couple.
He sucks, okay? He's a very bad protagonist. He's not fun to watch, he's pathetic, and I guess that makes him the
perfect kind of person to fall in love with his toaster. The robot is fine but, due to being a robot, she's just a robot.
So, I guess my question is this: Why are we watching this? They're not very cute together, and since most of the show
is just them doing things, I'm not sure what the point is. There are some things to be discussed about a robot's ability
to love and all that normal stuff, but it's not explored in depth. It's just a slice-of-life thing.
Long Story Short
My Wife Has No Emotion fails mostly due to its protagonist and lack of depth. |
---|
Review
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Narenare -Cheer for You!- has an interesting premise that it doesn't capitalize on. It follows a bunch of cute anime
girls who come together to ... do things, sometimes. They all have their skills - cheerleading, parkour, content
creation - and use them to, like I said, do things. Sometimes. What things? Ostensibly, things that involve
supporting others. The girls also need to overcome their individual obstacles, which they can do with the help of each other.
But it kind of falls apart. There are too many characters who don't receive enough depth or development, and the things
that they do all feel pretty surface-level. There are some good moments but it's hard to separate them from the more
monotonous ones that fill a lot of the running time. It's a lot of middling CGDCT antics. It looks nice - P.A. Works
is one of the Good Ones™ - but it's hard to recommend the anime.
Long Story Short
Narenare -Cheer for You!- needed a greater focus. |
---|
Review
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
No Longer Allowed In Another World is one of those anime with a central premise that made me do a double-take
before watching it. It feels ... disrespectful. Real-life author Osamu Dazai gets sent on an isekai adventure after truck-
kun gets in the way of his suicide plans. And then once there, he spends a lot of his time trying or hoping to complete
that plan, all while his new adventuring buddies try to stop him. He inadvertently saves the day while looking for ways
to die.
I can't remember if the anime mentions his name or just heavily implies it - he's called "Sensei" most or all of the time.
But you can see why this feels wrong, right? Getting past that, it's a pretty solid show. The animation is strong,
the characters are memorable - Tama <3 - and some of the individual challenges they face are both compelling and
thematically deep. It just feels kind of wrong, and until you get over that it's hard to have a good time. Once you do?
Yeah, it's a solid show.
Long Story Short
It feels wrong to like No Longer Allowed In Another World, but here we are. |
---|
Review
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Hey, anime fan! Yes, you. Did you like Solo Leveling but thought there was too much animation and weren't
enough lolis? Well boy do I have an anime for you. And also a ride in a cop car. A Nobody's Way Up to an
Exploration Hero is set in a world where dungeons are commercially run experiences, and our hero ("hero") spends
his free time going to them even though the cute childhood friend character who is in his class and lives near him and
very clearly likes him doesn't want him to.
He finds rare drops that allow him to summon lolis to clear the dungeon for him and teams up with other girls who, in
one terrible episode, all fall in love with him for no reason. There is nothing of consequence that happens in this
show. It's abysmal. It looks awful, its characters have one personality trait if they're lucky, and we never accomplish
anything. It's an utter waste of time.
Long Story Short
A Nobody's Way Up to an Exploration Hero deserves prison. As do you, maybe, if you like it. |
---|
Review
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
For a not-insignificant portion of The Ossan Newbie Adventurer, Trained to Death by the Most Powerful Party,
Became Invincible's runtime, it was rated significantly lower than its current score. It has a rough start, where
we get to watch our OP protagonist act like an idiot. He doesn't think he's strong, you see. And ... I guess I'm just sick
of these "aww, shucks, I'm actually really weak you know" OP protagonists. So YMMV on how much you hate him at
this point in the show.
He eventually learns that, no, he's actually really strong, and the show improves significantly once we start getting into
the meat of the story. It's at this point it is almost over, and we get told (not directly, but with no S2 announcement) to
go read the source material. At least we get some entertaining parts to try to entice us to do so. I won't be following
those instructions, but maybe you will. Or you could just start there if you're going to eventually do that anyway.
Long Story Short
The Ossan Newbie Adventurer wastes too much time on the bad stuff and, once it starts getting good, it ends. |
---|
Review
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
A few minutes into Plus-Sized Elf, you'll conclude that this is a fetish anime. And if you are not
someone who has that fetish, it will be a painful watch. The premise here is that an elf came to our world and got
addicted to our junk food, and she can't go back to her world unless she's the same weight she was when
she got here. So she finds a dude and tries to lose weight. And then we meet a bunch of other overweight monster
girls who all have similar goals.
The saving grace of the show is that it's a half-length series, so each episode only hurts for half the normal time.
None of the girls get any time to do anything beyond show us their one personality trait, the art is bad even for
a fetish show, and it's so repetitive that you feel like you watch the same episode over and over with some of the
Mad Libs nouns and verbs swapped.
Long Story Short
If you do not have the specific fetish Plus-Sized Elf is catering to, avoid it. |
---|
Review
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Pseudo Harem is adorable. It follows a dude and a girl as they spend time together, with the central gimmick being
they're in the drama club and the girl is good at acting. So she decides to portray multiple stereotypes to
effectively give the dude his own harem ... of just her, acting. Hence the title. So you'll see them hanging out, and then
she'll switch to one of these roles, then quickly to another, and it continues - depending on the situation.
It's an excuse for Saori Hayami to carry a show with voice acting. And it works! She is tremendous - you
already know this, if you pay any attention to who voices in the anime you like - but this allows her to show her
range over and over again. The comedy is hit-or-miss, the animation is sometimes not very good, and especially in
its first half it gets a bit repetitive. But it's worth sticking around to the end. And Saori Hayami is just so good.
Long Story Short
Pseudo Harem is a cute anime carried by one of its lead actors. |
---|
Review
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
If you ever thought being a video game tester is all fun and games, here comes Quality Assurance in Another
World to tell you that it isn't, actually, assuming you get trapped in the video game and you're also someone who
is so dedicated to your job that you continue running into walls looking for out-of-bounds glitches even when your
life is on the line. That's what happens to a bunch of testers of the game in this anime, and while most of the testers
decide to abuse their abilities - god mode, etc. - our protagonist is a good boi who would never do such a thing!
Eventually, a story happens beyond this, and there are mini-quests and whatnot that he and his new companions have
to go on. It's duller than I expected given the pretty fun opening episode. There isn't a lot to the characters, the world
of the game isn't very fun to explore, and the central gimmick loses its appeal pretty quickly. It usually looks pretty
decent, and it's never completely boring, but I can't be the only one who expected them to do more with this
concept.
Long Story Short
Quality Assurance in Another World: Cool idea, lacking execution. |
---|
Review
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Picture this. You're an office worker who just wants some ramen. So you go to the closest ramen shop and upon
entering you're greeted by a sassy talking cat. And behind the counter is another cat. And all the workers are cats.
And there's a sign saying "hey sorry buddy but there might be cat hair in your ramen, no refunds offered." The place
is packed despite this. That is the store at the center of Ramen Akaneko, which hires a human girl in its first
episode and spends its running time on the various antics of the store.
It's not a tough gimmick to sell in an anime, although it would be in real life. But, yeah, we get to spend time with the
various cats, as seen through the human worker's eyes. Not much happens that is consequential - while it's not
listed as an iyashikei, it could've been. It's not even put as a slice-of-life, because MAL doesn't believe a slice-of-
life can also be a comedy, for some reason. The show didn't make me laugh a whole lot or make me feel much of
anything. It's passable entertainment but that's about it.
Long Story Short
If you want to see a workplace comedy in a ramen shop with talking cats, I guess we now have that. |
---|
Review
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
I've never played the Sakuna: Of Rice and Ruin video game, but I've got a pretty good idea of what it is based
on its anime adaptation. A childlike goddess is banished to a demon-filled island along with a group of humans, and
once there they have to (1) grow rice and (2) fight demons. I've also never grown rice, but after watching the tedium
involved here, I hope I never will. I also, funnily enough, don't think I'll ever want to play the video game that the anime
is advertising, so I guess it's a failure in that aspect.
The thing is, it's pretty boring. It's pretty, too - thank you P.A. Works once again - but it's dull. And the characters are
more annoying than endearing. Look, I know there's an audience out there who want Stardew Valley but also
action, and that's the target group for the video game. It makes sense. Not for me, I don't think. I've now experienced
this anime, so I'm good. 13 episodes of boring rice growing with occasional bursts of demon-fighting were enough.
Long Story Short
Sakuna: Of Rice and Ruin doesn't have enough going on for me, and its characters annoyed me. |
---|
Review
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Senpai Is an Otokonoko is an anime about a teenage boy who likes to dress up as a girl. And his best friend who
probably loves him, romantically, but struggles to accept that. And his new friend who proclaims her love for him but
maybe doesn't know what she feels. It's a complicated mess of feelings that begin to unwind throughout its 12 episodes. It has some twists and turns in its story, some drama that feels earned and other drama that doesn't.
But its heart is in the right place and there's a lot to be gained from watching it, especially if you're someone who isn't
the most accepting of others who are different from you. And you're on MAL, so there's like a 69.42% chance that's you.
Where it falters is in that unearned drama - sometimes characters just do things that don't feel like they make sense
given what we know, and it causes a lot of headaches - in its production quality, and in not finishing its story. We got
a movie sequel announced, though, so that's not too big of a problem. The production leans heavily on chibi reaction
shots that start as a fun gag and eventually become a crutch to keep the project going. At least it didn't suffer
non-Olympic-related delays, unlike other shows from the studio.
Long Story Short
Senpai Is an Otokonoko has enough to say to make it worth sticking through its mediocre production. |
---|
Review
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
There's an episode early on in Shoshimin: How to Become Ordinary where the entire episode is centered on figuring
out how a guy made hot chocolate without dirtying more dishes than seems necessary. I feel like that's going to be a
pretty good litmus test when it comes to this show. If you are entertained by that, you'll be here for the long haul. If
you aren't, goodbye. It's a show all about solving little mysteries - until it does a bigger one at the end - and you need
to accept that. It's by the Hyouka author and its stakes are generally lower.
It's gorgeous. They put a more cinematic aspect ratio on it, and while that could just be a trick to make us feel like it's
more visually impressive than it is, it works. The two leads have such fun dialogue exchanges with each other that
even when they're solving banal mysteries, you don't wind up caring. If this is your type of show, you're going to love
it. If it's not, well, the hot chocolate episode will filter you out.
Long Story Short
Shoshimin: How to Become Ordinary is an absolute delight. |
---|
Review
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
The Strongest Magician in the Demon Lord's Army Was a Human. Didn't we do this recently? Like a few times?
Whatever, I guess it's not like seasonal fantasy anime are generally known for their originality anyway. This one
has our protagonist hiding he's a human from most of the army - even though everyone of importance knows,
whether he knows they know or not - and commanding his troops to beat the baddies from behind a mask. Oh, and
he takes in a human maid.
There's nothing to this show. There's no substance there. We got through like two "arcs" and learn nothing about
anyone of consequence. Things progress exactly how you'd expect given our protagonist is, as the title tells us,
the strongest magician. There isn't any strong action or animation, the characters are bland, and the story is the most
could've-been-AI junk out there. The only reason I'll remember this show in a year is because of the demon lord
being a cutie.
Long Story Short
The Strongest Magician in the Demon Lord's Army Was a Human kind of tells you all you need to know, huh? |
---|
Review
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Suicide Squad Isekai sounds like a bananas concept. You take the DC supervillain team and transport them to
another world. What crazy shenanigans will they get up to? Disappointingly few, it turns out. They mostly just work,
reluctantly, with one of the armies of the world they get sent to, fighting another army that also has other DC
characters working with it. Is it fun? Yeah, but it should've been way more.
The action scenes vary in animation quality - the middle episodes are worse off, not that this is unusual for anime -
and it never feels like the stakes are particularly high. It's a bit repetitive, too. On the other hand, it gave us
Anime Harley Quinn, which should give it 3 points on its own. Okay, okay, she's been in anime before, but not
as front and center as here, and - look, she's really fun to watch. The show around her is fine if unremarkable, but
if you're a fan you kind of need to watch it regardless.
Long Story Short
Suicide Squad Isekai is fine but nothing special, but it gave us Anime Harley Quinn for extended periods. |
---|
Review
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Confession time: I am an unfortunate simp for the Terminator franchise. I even - and this is when I was getting
paid to write movie reviews - gave a positive review to Genisys. It was a tepidly positive review, but I nevertheless
recommended it. Do I stand by that? I'd have to rewatch it to know for sure. It's been nearly a decade. The point is,
especially on a first watch, a new Terminator installment is something that I always look forward to, and now that
Terminator is anime, of course I'm going to enjoy that.
Terminator Zero follows a scientist in Japan working on an AI to compete with Skynet, hoping to prevent
doomsday from that perspective. There's some really interesting stuff regarding the AI and its "conscience," if you
can call it that. Also, Skynet sends a Terminator back to the past to kill him, a human also gets sent back, and it
falls back on a tried and true formula ... for some of its running time. There's some new stuff in there, too. And I
had a good time. Will I think back as fondly on it in 10 years? Who knows? But I like it now and if you like the series
then you probably will, too.
Long Story Short
Terminator Zero is a Terminator anime and I am here for it. |
---|
Review
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
I am an incredibly firm believer that you should go out of your way to experience things that are not necessarily made
for you - especially with media. It's good advice for many aspects of life, but I'm a coward, so I'll stick to media for
which I'm not the target audience. BL is not my genre of choice, mostly due to how the stories are generally told.
Twilight Out of Focus is a BL show that initially tells the story of two roommates as they fall in love while making
a short movie. And just as I was starting to care about them and their relationship, the anime switched focus to two
other dudes.
This happens again. It's introductory episodes for 3 couples - the "how did you guys start dating" story - but doesn't
get much beyond that. Any of these 3 stories could've been fine as its own anime. It might've even been effective to
layer them together, cutting back between them. But to go 4 straight episodes, and then to just completely switch
focus right as we might be getting invested? Sorry, didn't work out. BL fans might still get something out of it but
it was a bad choice in my opinion.
Long Story Short
Twilight Out of Focus made a bad choice that stopped me from investing in its characters. |
---|
Review
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
VTubers have taken off since the Covid pandemic. You're an anime fan, so you know this. You, statistically,
probably watch or have watched them. I did! I don't anymore, apart from random clips that get sent to me from
friends (yes I have friends) or the YouTube algorithm. And while I don't think they're at their height in terms of
popularity, that makes them the perfect target to get an anime. And not some NFT-shilling piece of garbage
masquerading as an anime this time. No, VTuber Legend: How I Went Viral after Forgetting to Turn Off My Stream
is one that feels like a behind-the-scenes into a real VTuber's life.
The VTuber at the center builds a mediocre career as a princess-type idol but forgets to end her stream properly
before unleashing her drunk, degenerate side. This goes viral, she finds newfound fame, and the anime shows how
she navigates this alongside her castmates. VTuber fans should love this. It bored me after the initial surge, sorry to
say. But it does feel a lot more realistic than anime's previous attempts at doing VTubers, so props to that.
Long Story Short
VTuber Legend will resonate strongly with VTuber fans. Everyone else will be left out of the loop. |
---|
Review
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
The irony to Why Does Nobody Remember Me in This World? is that, when writing up these little blurbs, I kind of
forgot that it existed. It's an anime about a dude who comes from a peaceful world, with a war between several
species having ended some time ago. He then gets magically transported to an identical world except that
war never ended there. Humans, therefore, are in a bad spot. But he has knowledge of how it ended, and gets a weapon
that was used to end it, so we, the audience, can be pretty sure he'll be able to save the day.
It looks generic, has bad action scenes, doesn't have a single memorable character or scene, and is another fantasy
anime to throw on the seasonal slop pile. I've heard the source material for this one isn't bad, but the anime makes
it feel like the blandest thing one could be subjected to. That keeps it out of the offensively bad territory - but, really,
feeling nothing toward something is worse than feeling hatred. There's nothing here.
Long Story Short
Why Does Nobody Remember Me in This World? is so forgettable I actually kind of forgot about it. |
---|
Review
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
I got worried a few episodes into Wistoria: Wand and Sword when it was delayed. Delays in anime aren't exactly
uncommon, but this one was, what, 3 or 4 episodes in? The animation up to that point was spectacular. We'd get one
super sakuga-heavy scene each episode, and it was a wonder to watch. Did they cause the delays? Were we in for
significantly worse animation going forward? We weren't. It kept delivering. The animation is the reason to watch this
anime.
The story? It's another "magicless dude goes to magic school" show. Our protagonist is chasing his childhood friend,
who is so skilled at magic she's already ascended to the tower that only the most bestest mages get to go to. And
despite not being able to do magic, he's gonna get there, too! He is, of course, gifted in other ways. The story is a
lot of nothing you haven't seen before. It's a show carried by its animation, but it's so strong in that aspect that it's
worth checking out.
Long Story Short
Wistoria: Wand and Sword is a lot of mediocrity held up by gorgeous animation. |
---|
Review
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
We got a few episodes into the second part of NieR:Automata Ver1.1a before I was feeling a little lost. I had
played the game, but only until the first ending, before the first season. Not wanting to do the B route (the same game
but with a different character), I skipped out on that. And then the anime got past where I was, and I decided to go do
that. So I played through the video game again, then the B route, then the rest of it. I was finally ready to experience
the anime and let me tell you: If you're only so-so on the gameplay of NieR:Automata, the anime is the best
way to experience the story.
Not only is it gorgeous, but you don't have to spend 6 hours replaying the same thing just to get to new content.
Miraculously, it turns out that wasn't necessary to get the point across! So, yeah, the anime tells its story more cleanly
than the video game, with much less wasted audience time and repetition. The changes it does make are usually
for the best, and it even has a few more tie-ins to earlier entries in the franchise. The game is fun but the gameplay
isn't my type of thing, especially with the repetitive and overused bullet hell segments. But the anime? This second
part, and the entire project now that it's whole, is great.
Long Story Short
NieR:Automata Ver1.1a is the best way to experience NieR:Automata. |
---|
Review
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
The first season of The Café Terrace and Its Goddesses was a fine show about a dude and a quintet of girls trying
to run a restaurant together, all while the harem shenanigans simmered in the background. So, how do you top that?
You add 5 more girls, but make them "evil" (heavy air quotes there) versions of the girls we already know. Yes, the
evil business dude decides to start a rival restaurant with its own goddesses. This lasts a few episodes before it
resolves and then everything is daijoubu.
Where does that leave us? With the harem stuff! And some restaurant stuff still pops up. The series got by in its
first season by highlighting the girls' main trait (musician, dork, ditz, etc.) but that isn't enough to carry it this time.
So it tries to add a little depth to them and has moderate success doing so - except how we need to spend time on
the new girls, too, which spreads everything a little too thin for my liking. If you like the girls then you'll enjoy
this season but if you were lukewarm or worse on the whole thing, it's not any better.
Long Story Short
The Café Terrace and Its Goddesses goes to show that adding more isn't always the best recipe. |
---|
Review
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
The first season of [Oshi No Ko] got one of my rare 10/10s. Would I stand by that? I think I would. It's a really strong
season with an exceptional opening episode and a week-to-week level of intrigue that few shows can match. The
second season has that same week-to-week hook - with an exception; we'll get to it - but it doesn't have that
fantastic opening to put it over the top. It's great stuff - although it doesn't give Ruby enough to do. It just lacks
that je ne sais quoi.
That exception I mentioned is the play. A bunch of the cast prepares for and then performs a play for a large portion
of the season. It's visually spectacular, thematically strong, very important for several of the participants ... and goes
on for like an episode too long, for me at least. It's just dragged out to the point where I was hoping it'd end. Ruby's
investigation takes a backseat for its entirety - there's still a lot going on, don't worry - and I kind of wanted to get
back to it. Maybe that's a "me" problem. Look, it's all awesome anyway, just perhaps a bit too long.
Long Story Short
[Oshi No Ko] continues to be great. |
---|
Review
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Shy would've won my "most okayest" anime award for its season if such an award existed. It was a serviceable
anime that did nothing special (except for, perhaps, its OP), and it came and went without a lot of fanfare. But then it
got a second season for some reason. And it's a little worse. You know the final arc of the first season that felt like it
went on for a couple of episodes too long? That's like the entire second half of this season. I just kept waiting for it to
end.
It revolves around a new character that I couldn't find myself caring much about, and that kind of dooms the whole arc.
It's not like they don't try; there's effort put into characterization, back story, and development, and it just didn't
resonate with me. So it's a drag. The production values remain decent but unremarkable, so you don't even get
tremendous action scenes to jolt you awake. But I will assume anyone watching Shy's second season for fun
is a fan and will get more out of it than I did.
Long Story Short
Shy's second season dragged more than the first. |
---|
Review
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
I refuse to believe that you remember much from Tower of God. That was, what, 4 years ago? I had to look at a
recap video for it, and even then most of the events the recap had made me go "Yeah, I guess that's something that
happened." And now we have this second season, years later, with a bunch of characters we don't know. We're back
climbing the tower, only even start to address the cliffhanger at the season one finale midway through, and does
anyone even care?
It doesn't feel like the same anime. The tower itself is just a thing with levels to overcome, our protagonist acts like
a completely different dude, most of the supporting cast is actually new, and the art and animation have taken a
dive, too. I don't want to say it's just due to the change in studio, but it might've been! There's no reason to invest
in this story anymore, and I assume anyone who was invested just went and read the source in the years since.
Long Story Short
The second season of Tower of God is too late, too mediocre, and I can't bring myself to care about it. |
---|
Review
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Kimi ni Todoke will stand as one of the shows that proves that, no, actually, the anime you love that you want more
seasons for wasn't abandoned completely; it was just put on indefinite hold! It was more than a decade from the
second season to this one, so that can give hope to anyone still waiting on future seasons of other shows. All you
need is Netflix to fund it! (Disclaimer: I don't know how much financial backing Netflix had in the third season of
Kimi ni Todoke: From Me to You.)
So, how is it? Well, it's five double-length episodes showing how the relationships progressed for our characters.
I imagine anyone who was mixed on earlier seasons would have forgotten most of the show by now, but those
who love it will be fully on board for more. I watched all of it in preparation for this third season, so it was fresh in
my mind. It's got strong characters and the story is told well. The misunderstandings aren't even that big of a deal
this time out. I'm glad we got this. I hope we get treatments like this for other shows.
Long Story Short
Kimi ni Todoke: From Me to You gets the third season it needs here. |
---|
This is where I will put the anime that are multiple cours, or suffered delays, and I can't realistically wait for them to conclude before releasing this retrospective. They will be moved to the "addendum" section once they conclude and I've finished them, but will not factor into the stats.
Review
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Review paragraph 1
Review paragraph 2
Long Story Short
Summary |
---|
Review
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Review paragraph 1
Review paragraph 2
Long Story Short
Summary |
---|
Review
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Review paragraph 1
Review paragraph 2
Long Story Short
Summary |
---|
Review
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Review paragraph 1
Review paragraph 2
Long Story Short
Summary |
---|
Monogatari Series: Off & Monster Season
It's tough, right? Most seasons don't give me two 9/10s, but Monogatari returned after being gone for so long so it's getting the award.![]() | ![]() | ![]() |
NieR:Automata Ver1.1a | Alya Sometimes Hides
Her Feelings in Russian | My Deer Friend Nokotan |
---|---|---|
![]() | ![]() | ![]() |
Shoshimin: How to
Become Ordinary | Monogatari Series: Off
& Monster Season | [Oshi no Ko] |
![]() | ![]() | ![]() |
Makeine: Too Many
Losing Heroines! | No Longer Allowed
In Another World | The Elusive Samurai |